Connection not Content

A Blog for MOOCs and Other Animals

Caring about Caring

with 6 comments

Once (and only once) and for a reason that escapes me now, the engineering professor had written the word ‘love’ on the blackboard, He stepped back and mused, “….don’t see that word often here …” and we males all shifted uncomfortably in our seats. At the time I thought him a little eccentric and behind the times. Rather than building on past successes his research had veered towards psychological and even philosophical aspects (OMG!). I preferred the nitty gritty of technical detail. He was not a particularly good administrator either but his door was always open and when I was in financial difficulties (more than once) he always managed to help. Not all the academic staff were so caring.

University engineering departments probably represent an extreme when it comes to caring about caring. In an almost all male environment it can be difficult to even discuss relationships let alone agree what needs to be done for the better. In particular, the small minority of female students, however academically gifted and self-assured, can find it difficult adjusting to an atmosphere of boyish geekiness and literal mindedness exhibited by some male students and academics.

Engineers – can they ever live a normal life? (Dilbert – The Knack; video via sillytoy)

Being a bit geeky and literal-minded myself and having no background in social sciences, much of the pedagogical discussion in MOOCMOOC either goes over my head or comes through too simply as exhortations to ‘Do Good!’. But I am invigorated by the stories of real teachers and real students and there have been some excellent thought-provoking examples of this. Some caring suggestions I came across could apply to the type of Higher Education environment I knew as a lecturer and I try to envisage the practicalities.

For example, turning up early at lectures for casual chat is one suggestion I considered (apologies as I can’t find who suggested this!). Sometimes students approach the lecturer before a lecture and conversation can flow but it’s not so easy when setting up overhead projectors, drawing curtains, dispensing handouts and attendance sheets, organising demonstrations etc and having to start more or less on time. For the career academic at a UK university, teaching, admin and research usually account for most working activity and in my experience (albeit last century) only the superhuman can balance all three satisfactorily. Promotion prospects hinge primarily on research and that involves travelling to meet potential sponsors, supervising research students and contracts, nail-biting applications for funding, ordering equipment and so on, not to mention actually doing research and writing it all up. The result is that teaching may come to be regarded as a secondary activity or even a necessary evil. Those taking the time to excel as teachers can be sidelined by a lack of publications.

Passion and involvement of the whole self are advocated and for good reason but displays of passion are not without danger. The prof I mentioned above liked and respected his young secretary but became worried that a goodnight kiss following a tequila-laden social event was a little too fond. So he apologised profusely to her the next day. Fortunately, to everyone else, including his secretary, this was nothing more than amusing evidence of his humanity and careful sense of propriety.

Most university academics probably recognise the benefits of getting to know students on a personal level but this can be difficult for practical reasons such as lecturing large numbers of students from different departments and can even be counter-productive if not approached with skill and maturity. The dean in Tom Lehrer’s comic song who “Tried so hard to be pals with us all” illustrates this nicely. These lines also highlight the stark ‘them and us’ divisions that can characterise university life.

To the beer and benzedrine,
To the way that the dean
Tried so hard to be pals with us all.
To excuses we fibbed,
To the papers we cribbed
From the genius who lived down the hall.

To the tables down at Morey’s (wherever that may be)
Let us drink a toast to all we love the best.
We will sleep through all the lectures,
And cheat on the exams,
And we’ll pass, and be forgotten with the rest.

Tom Lehrer – Bright College Days (video via slayerowns666)

The trouble with ‘linear’ subjects such as engineering, or STEM in general, is that there actually is a considerable amount of content that has to be transmitted into heads one way or another before moving on to a next stage. Yes, tutorials can be used to get to know students, problems can be framed authentically to spark interest and engagement but can calculus or circuit theory ever have the same potential for intimate discussion and reflection as poetry, art or philosophy?

UK universities seem better prepared for personal interaction between academic staff and students these days. There are formal systems such as staff/student committees and personal tutor schemes in place for mentoring and identifying collective and individual student problems. Personal tutors are encouraged to meet regularly with their tutees helping them with any type of problem arising but again, properly keeping track of perhaps 8 tutees is time consuming and may not be regarded by some tutors (or students!) as important. When borderline exam results are discussed in the privacy of examiners’ meetings the input provided by personal tutors can be crucial for fair decision making. Sadly, some tutors may have little to contribute – some may not even recognise the names of their tutees!

All sorts of practical issues bedevil good healthy interaction between academic staff and students. Perhaps things will change with the climate of opinion inside universities but I find this difficult to envisage without systemic change and proper resourcing.

Written by Gordon Lockhart

January 30, 2015 at 5:19 pm

Posted in Uncategorized

Tagged with , ,

6 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. As the wife of an engineer I loved this Dilbert 🙂 I appreciate the problem of teaching “linear” subjects, but I think it is still possible to create more caring classrooms. I’m a big fan of students teaching each other, and think that dojo style learning design, or Jigsaw Classroom type models ( could be effective in maths and engineering. I’ve found when I set my classrooms up these sorts of ways I can actually interact more personally with students.

    Nomad War Machine

    January 30, 2015 at 5:55 pm

    • Thanks Sarah. Yes, students teaching each other can be very effective. I recall (years ago at Aberdeen University) first year maths students being formally tutored by students who excelled in the same course the year before. I don’t know why it’s not more common – seems ideal for basic STEM material and know how. I looked at jigsaw and it seems to have potential at university level. The main problem would probably be to convince academic staff, or the powers that be to commit resources to teaching innovation.

      Gordon Lockhart

      January 30, 2015 at 7:54 pm

  2. Great post. It immediately made me think about Eric Mazur. I haven’t seen anywhere that Eric Mazur cares about caring, but he certainly cares about teaching – I went through the whole of my undergraduate degree (also a science subject and many moons ago!) without a single lecturer knowing my name. I think I might have been able to cope with that if the teaching had been good! I can relate to your post on many levels. Thank you.


    January 30, 2015 at 6:55 pm

    • I had forgotten about Mazur though I saw the video some time ago. I like most of what he says, particularly on the efficacy of traditional assessment but looking at accounts of alternative teaching strategies I sometimes find it difficult to figure out what success is down to the charisma and exceptional teaching abilities of the practitioner as opposed to the strategy itself.

      As for names, large classes can make it difficult to remember names but certainly some lecturers seem to manage it considerably better than others! Thanks for your comments Jenny.

      Gordon Lockhart

      January 31, 2015 at 8:01 am

  3. A teaching and learning task force I served on looked at some of these programs (and Mazur is mentioned). There are lots of challenges with how the “flipping” is sometimes used, but in an information rich time, I’m intrigued by the idea that class time no longer needs to be as focused on information dissemination.

    The caring part is a challenge in the frenzy that shapes so much of university life. I keep trying to think about what I can change this year, and over the next five years. Otherwise change sometimes seems so daunting that it’s hard to even try. Thanks again for the great post.


    January 30, 2015 at 9:40 pm

    • Thanks for commenting – “flipping” does seem to be catching on. I’ve no experience of it myself but anything that encourages students to study more uniformly rather than making frenzied efforts just before a final exam seems worthwhile. I’m fairly convinced now about moving the focus from information dissemination to learning. I used to upload lecture notes to our university intranet for students but only after giving each conventional lecture. I think now I’d try to make the lectures far more interactive and upload all notes at the start of the course.

      Being retired, I don’t have to think too seriously about change any more. When it comes to innovation, thinking ‘outside the box’ seems to lead too often to extra staff loading when the box itself probably needs attention!

      Gordon Lockhart

      January 31, 2015 at 1:54 pm

Leave a Reply to Gordon Lockhart Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: